Metal Roof Vs Shingles in a Hurricane

When it comes to re-roofing their home, Florida homeowners have two primary alternatives: metal roofing and asphalt shingles. There are also various natural options available, such as wood and stone. Outside of the attic space, you should think about cost, durability, hurricane, and storm resistance, added home value, energy efficiency, lifespan, and overall performance. When it comes to choosing the finest quality roof, more elements should be taken into account than simply visual appeal.

Choosing a roofing material is a personal decision that depends on your budget and the characteristics you care about most in your new roof. To figure this out, you'll need to compare the characteristics of metal roofing and asphalt shingles head-to-head.

This is one amazing metal roof - Metal Roof Vs Shingles in a Hurricane


When it comes to longevity, metal roofs are the clear winners. Metal roofs are covered by warranties that demonstrate their dependability and durability. Metal roofs, on the other hand, frequently come with a lifetime guarantee. Metal roofing lifespans are usually much longer.

Shingles, on the other hand, can outperform metal roofing alternatives like aluminum in the event of significant winds. When it comes to shingles vs. metal roofing, there are a few things you should know ahead of time. While this may appear to be a superior choice given the idea of a heavier roof being more difficult to break, it isn't always the case.

Building contractor is installing metal roofing sheets on the rooftop of the house using electric screwdriver.


Asphalt shingles can withstand a great deal of rain and wind. However, these roofs are unable to withstand winds of more than 130 mph, and their wind resistance decreases dramatically as they age. A metal roof will withstand stronger winds, as it can survive hurricane-force winds without shingles.

When comparing metal and tile roofs, it's important to keep in mind that metals withstood winds of over 140 or 150 mph, making them the most weather-resistant of the two types. Metal roofs are less durable than shingles when it comes to hurricanes and storms, but they are more prone to dents. Hail damage to a metal roof may be more severe than that to a shingle roof. However, this does not imply that shingle roofs are entirely resistant to hail damage.

It's a good idea to have a metal roof in Florida, which is known for storms.

close up view of house under construction with grey folding roof on waterproofing layer

What type of roofing material adds the most value to your property?

A metal roof has a steeper upfront price, although it does have a higher resale value, usually by 1 to 6 percent. Resale values are also determined by the area in which an item may be used. Residents of Florida will be relieved to learn that a metal roof's ROI on the east coast is around 95%, compared to 85% on the west. Roofing choices for your home will vary from those of other houses on the market. While this may deter some potential purchasers, it will not affect the value or overall ROI of your property.

Shingles do not add much value to your property, even though they may be worthwhile in other states. This is because shingles are the most prevalent roofing material in Florida. A new metal roof, in particular, will have a greater influence on the value of your house than a comparable new roof.

This is one amazing metal roof.


Metal roofs can provide significant insulation for your home. A metal roof, when compared to an asphalt shingle roof, saves you 25% in energy consumption. Choose a light-colored metal roof to better reflect heat and produce more savings.

Let's look at the energy savings in more detail. Every month, the typical family pays $100 in energy expenses. When you put a metal roof on your property, the cost drops by roughly $25 each month, leaving you with a monthly energy bill of just $75. You'll save approximately $300 over a year.

Shingle roofs are excellent heat conductors, but they can be uncomfortable in the summer. Metal roofing also has the advantage of being more durable and long-lasting than asphalt shingle roofs. It is also fire resistant, which means you may sleep safe in your home knowing that if there is a fire it will not damage or harm your property. Another way metal roofing benefits the environment is by reducing carbon emissions considerably when compared to traditional. Shingles can be recycled, but not all types. It's possible that if you don't have a certain shingle type on your roof, it will end up in the garbage. Solar cells are another example of a product, like a solar panel or an electric car, that requires more time and attention to upkeep than standard roof tile. Solar roofs can have several advantages over traditional ones.


A metal roof will most likely cost twice as much as an asphalt shingle roof: $18,000 and $9,000 respectively. However, the time element plays a significant role in total costs associated with a roof. Let's look at it another way:

A metal roof will cost around $18,000 over its 60-year lifespan.

A three-layer shingle roof costs $9,000 per layer, or $27,000 for the entire structure (three 20-year lifespans).

Metal roofs are the most long-term roofing investment for your house, but they are also one of the most expensive types of roofs available. While you might spend fewer Metal roofs are more than three times as long-lasting and give you greater peace of mind, so if you're looking to stay in your house for many years, an asphalt shingle roof is a worse financial option.

Asphalt Shingle Roof


There are approximately 7,860 roofing contractors in Florida, and you don't want to hire the wrong one. There are many different types of roofs available for you to install on your home. No matter what sort of roof you choose, it will require the assistance of a top-not shaving firm to put it correctly. The following items will be safer if your roof is installed by professionals:

  • More Efficient – Roofing contractors who have experience can get your roof installed promptly while still maintaining quality.
  • Higher Quality – Although you can't guarantee the roofing material or installation if you use an unscrupulous roof contractor, this isn't a problem when working with reputable roofers in your region.
  • Safer Option – You may easily get injured if you try to install a roof yourself because of a lack of experience and few to no safety measures being employed during installation. Roofing contractors that are properly trained and equipped to do the job safely have been a valued resource for our customers for years.
  • Less Costly – It's more expensive to replace your roofing yourself or hire a poorly-rated firm than it is to work with an established business. Roofing contractors already have all of the necessary equipment and may buy roofing materials at a lower price because of their connections with manufacturers. If you do it yourself, you won't get the same discounts and will have to buy all of the materials.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *